On October 8th, a surprising turn of events unfolded in the Hong Kong stock market following several days of trading that showcased a remarkable pace of declineUnlike the previous surge seen in the A-shares market, the Hang Seng Index displayed a fiery green hue that starkly contrasted with the booming A-shares, indicating a potential divergence between the two marketsThis divergence raised eyebrows among investors, particularly given the backdrop of a resurgent A-share market bolstered by favorable factors including lower interest rates and renewed foreign investment in China.

The Hong Kong stocks opened high but faced a substantial downturn, with the Hang Seng Index dipping nearly 10% at one point, effectively wiping out gains accrued during the holiday periodThis decline was primarily attributed to significant losses in financial stocks, especially those of Chinese brokerages, which became the driving force behind the drop in the Hang Seng IndexMajor firms such as China Merchants Securities, Orient Securities, and CICC reported staggering losses exceeding 30%, while even leading brokerage firms like CITIC Securities saw their share prices decline by 23.54%.

The chaos extended beyond brokerages, spilling over to primary insurance companies on the mainland, with several of the most reputable firms witnessing share price falls exceeding 20%. Strikingly, Vanke, which had previously led the charge in Hong Kong, also plummeted by 31.54% on the same dayOther notable Hong Kong stocks experienced declines: NetEase fell by 10.87%, Meituan saw a drop of 15.65%, Tencent decreased by 8.32%, and prominent electric vehicle manufacturers such as Li Auto and Nio faced losses of 12.88% and 14.51%, respectively, while Alibaba declined by 8.81%.

Interestingly, Tencent, one of the more famous names in the Hong Kong market, witnessed a comparatively milder decline, partially due to its buyback program on October 7th, which amounted to HKD 502 million for 1.05 million shares at prices ranging from HKD 470 to HKD 482.2. Its aggressive repurchasing, totaling HKD 89.15 billion since the beginning of the year, helped stabilize its stock price amidst an overall day of turbulence, marking a decline of over 8% nonetheless.

Despite the market's pronounced drop, trading volumes set new records

Advertisements

The Hang Seng Index fell by over 8%, yet trading exceeded HKD 550 billion, maintaining high activity levels consistent with record highs from previous sessionsThe Hang Seng Tech Index also saw substantial trading at above HKD 150 billion, despite a decline exceeding 11%.

In a time of reduced dollar pressure and the return of foreign investment to the Chinese market, the A-share market thrived while the Hong Kong stocks faced their steepest declines in recent historyThis contrast has sparked speculation about a new wave of stock market volatility.

The influx of capital toward the A-share market has had a siphoning effect from Hong Kong equitiesThe significant volatility in Hong Kong stocks, while alarming to some, seemed rational to many investorsAnalyzing the market's movements, it was evident that a blend of internal and external factors contributed to this sudden downturn.

After the U.SFederal Reserve announced considerable interest rate cuts, Chinese assets surged remarkably, affecting not only the A-shares but also the broader footprint of Chinese enterprises listed abroadThe A50 futures contract even reached historic highs in its positions, indicating increased volatility potential in the landscapeConversely, as U.S. interest rate cut expectations diminished, the dollar index and treasury yields surged, further aggravating the declines in the Hong Kong market.

The capital inflow into A-shares during the National Day holiday, when the A-shares were closed for trading, led many foreign investors to seek refuge in Hong Kong stocks temporarilyHowever, as the A-shares resumed trading, the trend of capital rotation shifted back towards the mainland market, leading to significant sell-offs in Hong Kong sharesAnalysts concluded that this downward trend in Hong Kong was not indicative of a fundamental shift in logic but rather a result of the gravitational pull exerted by rising A-share valuations.

Several financial experts pointed out the increased attention of capital investment within A-shares, as signs of a correction began to manifest

Advertisements

With the Hang Seng Index observing notable overselling and technical indicators showing overbought conditions, the subsequent declines of the index appeared reasonableInvestors eager to capitalize on popular sectors needed to exercise caution, as the acknowledgment of a bull market does not guarantee relentless upward movement.

As the National Day holiday fostered a robust rally in the A-shares, the Hang Seng index saw a gain from 21,133.68 points to 23,241.74 points, a remarkable 10% increase over four trading daysAn analysis of the top performers revealed eight of the top ten companies were also listed in A-shares, with only Ease Technology and China Cinda not dual-listed.

In a more in-depth investigation, it became apparent that the top rising firms included prominent brokerage houses, such as China Merchants Securities and CITIC Securities, revealing that the brokerage sector in Hong Kong had undergone significant valuation recovery during the holiday periodAlthough this recovery was momentous, it likely sowed the seeds for the severe subsequent depreciation in these stocks once the A-shares opened post-holiday.

Financial analyst Xu Yi pointed out that the A/H premium and the arbitrage opportunities presented by brokerage stocks were substantial contributing factors to the remarkable surge in the Hong Kong marketThe restoration of the A/H premium seemed crucial for the current bullish movement in Hong Kong, with several brokerage firms such as Huayi Securities and Zhejiang Seabright enjoying enhanced premium ratesHowever, with the dramatic increases seen during the holiday, some premium rates started to turn negative, indicating scenarios where Hong Kong shares prices eclipsed their A-share counterparts.

Currently, the total number of listed companies with both A and H shares stands at 149. Interestingly, all A-share prices were above their H-share counterparts as of September 30, yet the latest data suggested a decrease in the overall A/H share price premium

Advertisements

By October 7, the aggregate premium for the A-shares over H-shares fell to 62.75%, showcasing a significant decline from the end of September, as the Hang Seng Index’s A/H premium index dropped to a four-year low.

Various sectors also witnessed significant activity patterns during the holiday, with securities, electrical grid equipment, semiconductors, aviation equipment, and new metals emerging as the top five sectorsThe securities sector profited immensely, leading to further extensions into technology sub-sectorsNotably, industry giants like Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation experienced a massive rise of 60% during this time, although on October 8th, they too fell significantly with an 18.32% decrease, although the subsequent day saw a slight recovery.

Globally recognized institutions maintain an optimistic outlook toward the Chinese stock marketThe unique characteristics of the Hong Kong financial environment create advantageous circumstances for stock investmentNumerous international organizations have expressed dedicated support for China's growth trajectory during the National Day, actively engaging in extensive research and discussions to forecast market behaviorA shared consensus among these agencies holds that the momentum in Chinese stocks will endure, sparking a more positive market outlook regarding future performance.

Goldman Sachs, in their report published on October 7, identified ten pivotal reasons bolstering positive sentiment toward the Chinese stock marketThese reasons encapsulated government policy initiatives, market responsiveness to these measures, and a relatively attractive valuation for Chinese stocks against global competitorsThe report further noted that the improvements in corporate profit expectations had driven favorable reactions from both retail and institutional investorsHistorical analysis suggests further significant room for growth, especially in light of favorable macroeconomic indicators.

Asset management firms like BlackRock and HSBC have also revised their recommendations on Chinese stocks, enhancing their ratings from neutral to overweight

Advertisements

Advertisements